There are dozens of book tracking apps now. Most of them do roughly the same thing: let you log books, set reading goals, and see how much you’ve read. The differences come down to what else they do, how they look, and what they do with your data.
We compared five of the most popular ones. Here’s how they stack up.
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Bookdot | Goodreads | StoryGraph | Literal | Bookly |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Platform | iOS | Web, iOS, Android | Web, iOS, Android | Web, iOS, Android | iOS, Android |
| Price | Free + Premium | Free | Free + Premium | Free + Premium | Free + Premium |
| Reading stats | Detailed | Basic | Detailed | Basic | Detailed |
| Social features | Minimal | Extensive | Moderate | Moderate | Minimal |
| Book discovery | Manual | Recommendations | Content-based | Community | Manual |
| Offline support | Full | Limited | No | No | Full |
| Notion sync | Yes | No | No | No | No |
| Reading timer | Yes | No | No | No | Yes |
| Privacy focus | High | Low | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate |
| Import from Goodreads | Yes | N/A | Yes | Yes | Yes |
1. Bookdot — for iOS readers who care about privacy
Bookdot is a native iOS app. Everything runs on your device with iCloud sync, so your reading data doesn’t go anywhere you haven’t chosen. There’s no account signup, no social feed, and no ads.
What it does well:
- Built-in reading timer that tracks how long each session lasts
- Stats that go deeper than “books per year” (pace, streaks, calendar view)
- Notes and highlights per book
- Notion sync, which no other reading tracker offers
- Home screen widgets
Where it falls short:
- iOS only. No Android, no web.
- Smaller book database than Goodreads
- If you want a reading community, this isn’t it
Pricing: Free to download. Premium unlocks unlimited bookshelves, detailed stats, and Notion sync.
Good fit if: You read on iPhone/iPad, you like your data staying on your device, and you’d rather track reading than talk about it.
2. Goodreads — for readers who want a community
Goodreads has 150 million members and the biggest book database around. It’s owned by Amazon, which means the catalog is massive but your data feeds into Amazon’s ad ecosystem.
What it does well:
- Largest book database and reader community
- Completely free
- Book clubs, discussion groups, author Q&As
- Available everywhere (web, iOS, Android)
Where it falls short:
- The app feels old. Slow loads, clunky navigation, no major redesign in years
- Privacy isn’t a priority. Amazon tracks your reading activity
- Reading stats are basic (books per year, that’s about it)
- No reading timer or session tracking
Pricing: Free.
Good fit if: You want to find reading friends, read reviews before picking a book, and don’t mind Amazon having your reading data.
3. StoryGraph — for readers who want better recommendations
StoryGraph was built as a direct Goodreads alternative. Its main selling point is recommendations based on mood, pace, and themes rather than what’s popular.
What it does well:
- Recommendation engine that actually considers what a book feels like to read
- Detailed reading stats with nice graphs
- Content warnings so you can avoid topics that bother you
- Independent, not owned by a tech company
Where it falls short:
- Smaller community than Goodreads
- Mobile apps feel like wrapped websites
- Limited offline support
- Some gaps in the book database for niche titles
Pricing: Free. Plus subscription ($4.99/month) for extra features.
Good fit if: You’re tired of Goodreads recommendations and want an app that understands reading preferences beyond genre.
4. Literal — for readers who want something simple
Literal is the minimalist option. Clean design, no clutter, and a growing community of readers who prefer a quieter space than Goodreads.
What it does well:
- Clean interface that’s easy on the eyes
- Curated reading community
- Nice book lists and collections
- Works across all platforms
Where it falls short:
- Smaller book database
- Not many reading stats
- Fewer features overall
- No timer or session tracking
Pricing: Free with optional premium.
Good fit if: You find Goodreads overwhelming and want something that just looks good and stays out of your way.
5. Bookly — for readers who like gamification
Bookly is all about the reading session. Timer, page tracking, achievements, streaks. It tries to make reading feel like a game you’re winning.
What it does well:
- Solid reading timer and page tracking
- Achievements and streaks that keep you motivated
- Good stats and charts
- Works offline
Where it falls short:
- Limited social features
- Smaller book database
- No integration with Notion or other tools
- Some features require the paid version
Pricing: Free with premium subscription for full features.
Good fit if: You want something that times your reading sessions and gives you a little dopamine hit for hitting your daily goal.
So which one?
Pick Bookdot if you want privacy, good stats, and Notion sync on iOS. Pick Goodreads if community and reviews matter most. Pick StoryGraph for better recommendations. Pick Literal if you want clean and simple. Pick Bookly if gamification keeps you reading.
Most of them are free to try, so you can just download two and see which one sticks.
Try Bookdot
Download Bookdot free on the App Store if you want a reading tracker that stays out of your way and keeps your data private.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the best book tracking app?
- The best book tracking app depends on your needs. Bookdot is best for iOS users who want a private, beautifully designed tracker with Notion sync. Goodreads has the largest community for social readers. StoryGraph excels at content-based recommendations. Literal is best for minimalists, and Bookly is ideal for focused reading session tracking.
- Is there a better alternative to Goodreads?
- Yes, several alternatives offer different strengths. Bookdot is a privacy-focused iOS app with better statistics and Notion sync. StoryGraph provides content-based recommendations without Amazon ownership concerns. Literal offers a clean, modern interface. The best alternative depends on whether you prioritize privacy, design, recommendations, or community features.
- Are book tracking apps free?
- Most book tracking apps offer free tiers. Goodreads is completely free. Bookdot, StoryGraph, and Literal are free with optional premium subscriptions for advanced features. Bookly offers a free version with a premium upgrade. Premium plans typically range from $2-10 per month.
- Can I import my Goodreads data to another app?
- Yes. Most book tracking apps support Goodreads CSV import. You can export your Goodreads library as a CSV file and import it into Bookdot, StoryGraph, Literal, or Bookly. The process typically takes just a few minutes.